The Alien Cat Theory: Why Aliens Might Be Ignoring Us

Could aliens be ignoring us with the same smug grace as cats? This fun and fascinating article explores the "alien cat theory" using the Drake Equation, Zoo Hypothesis, and feline behavior as a lens. Maybe we're not alone... just not interesting enough. Yet.

By David W. Falls

Quick Summary:
In this witty and thought-provoking article, David W. Falls suggests that aliens might behave like cats – observant, selective, and often indifferent. Using the Zoo Hypothesis and Drake Equation, he questions whether extraterrestrial silence is rejection – or cosmic discretion. The piece introduces the playful Cat Equation to explain our ongoing wait for contact, inviting readers to ponder, laugh, and stargaze with new eyes.

Seeking the Unknown: Cosmic Curiosity and Feline Intelligence

It’s fascinating, isn’t it? Contemplating the possibility of intelligent life thriving somewhere beyond our planet. The act of looking up at the night sky is almost universal – our oldest shared ritual. Ancient civilizations shared legends and told stories about constellations, treated the heavens as divine, and wondered if someone, somewhere, might be looking back. From the first whispers of myth to modern telescopes scanning the cosmos, humanity has always sought a connection beyond our earthly bounds – always wondering: are we alone?

Perhaps, in our search for intelligent life, we’ve overlooked a species that has already perfected the art of silent observation – watching, waiting, yet always just out of reach. Maybe the answer has been lounging in front of us all along – purring with quiet superiority. What if aliens not only resemble cats in their aloof nature, but actually think like them? Operating entirely on their own terms, revealing only what suits them – never more, never less.

The Silence of the Cosmos

And if alien minds operate like those of cats – observing, withholding, indifferent to our attempts at communication – maybe that explains the silence. Across the unfathomable expanse of the cosmos, the question lingers: Are they really out there? With countless stars and even more planets, the odds seem stacked in favor of other intelligent life. The Milky Way galaxy is estimated to contain around 100 to 400 billion stars. On average, there are estimated to be about 1 to 2 planets per star.

Yet, the cosmos remains eerily silent – no drifting probes, no gravitational anomalies, no remnants of alien craftsmanship. No detectable technosignatures, no grand megastructures reshaping the stars. But perhaps we’re not missing their signals – perhaps they’ve simply chosen not to send them – leaving us to wonder: Are we truly alone in this vast, ancient universe?

Our Milky Way Galaxy
Our Milky Way Galaxy

A Singular Anomaly: The Wow! Signal

Yet, despite the apparent emptiness, there has been one tantalizing anomaly – the Wow! Signal. Detected in 1977 by astronomer Jerry Ehman, it was an unexplained 72-second radio burst originating from deep space. Strong, isolated, and never repeated, it remains one of the greatest unsolved mysteries in the search for alien life.

But what if it was just the cosmic equivalent of a cat yelling in the dead of night? A single, inexplicable yowl, meant to disorient us before vanishing forever into the void.

Like my cat howling at 3 AM, the Wow! Signal may be the universe’s version of an unanswered late-night call.

Search for Life in a Vast Ocean of Stars

While scientific efforts continue to explore the cosmos for signs of life, the vastness of space and the limits of current technology leave us without definitive answers.
Despite breakthroughs in radio, ultraviolet, and infrared telescopes, humanity has barely scratched the surface of the universe – our observations still cover only a tiny fraction of the vast cosmic expanse.

To put it in perspective: the observable universe spans about 93 billion light-years in diameter, while our efforts to detect extraterrestrial signals – like radio waves – have only reached a relatively tiny “bubble” around Earth, about 100 light-years in radius.

Just as scooping a small amount of water from the ocean doesn’t guarantee you’ll find fish – or any sign of living organisms – it’s possible that our efforts to search for extraterrestrial life are limited by the scale and methods we’re using. Despite the ocean being teeming with organisms, a small sample may appear lifeless; and we would be incorrect to conclude that the ocean harbors no life.

Selective Attention: If Aliens Are Like Cats, We’ll Never Get a Straight Answer

Similarly, the universe could be full of intelligent civilizations, but our technology and current approaches might simply not reach them – or they may not care. Much like when I call my cats, Frankie and Ele – who hear me perfectly well yet choose to vanish, ignoring me as a matter of principle. Could extraterrestrials share this cryptic tendency? Simply observing us from a distance, choosing when and how to respond based on their own preferences rather than ours.

Absence of response doesn’t mean absence of existence; it may just mean that, like cats, extraterrestrial life operates on its own terms, answering only when it suits them – or perhaps it’s simply a matter of sheer laziness.

Typically, my cats will sleep 12 to 16 hours a day, conserving energy unless food or admiration is involved. Like cats, extraterrestrials may have mastered the art of conservation – reaching an evolutionary peak of leisure where venturing beyond their celestial windowsills simply isn’t worth the effort.

Frankie and Ele
Frankie and Ele

The Cosmic Cat Approach: When Engagement Is a Choice

Advanced beings may have learned that expending vast resources for interstellar communication or travel is simply impractical. The energy demands of warping space, quantum tunneling, and traversing wormholes may be so immense that such civilizations have chosen selective, deliberate engagement – waiting patiently, assessing, and only acting when the conditions are precisely right. If this careful selectivity defines their approach to the cosmos, it might also shape their interactions with us.

And if selective engagement shapes their nature, earning their trust might be as delicate as winning over a wary cat. Diplomacy will require patience, respect, and an understanding of boundaries. Rushing in will only push them further into the shadows. We’ll have to wait, observe, and let them decide when and how to respond – just as any cat owner knows all too well. Perhaps their silence isn’t rejection, but discretion.

The Zoo Hypothesis

If aliens exist, they may not be the hyper-logical beings we envision, tirelessly pursuing interstellar diplomacy. Perhaps, like cats, they have little interest in explaining themselves. Despite countless interrogations, my own cats remain steadfast in their silence – unwavering, inscrutable, and wholly indifferent to my inquiries. Maybe extraterrestrials observe us with the same quiet detachment – waiting for us to prove ourselves worthy of acknowledgment.

One scientific perspective that echoes this idea is the Zoo Hypothesis (Wikipedia) – the notion that advanced extraterrestrial beings may deliberately avoid direct interaction with us, watching from afar rather than interfering. They might be waiting for humanity to reach a certain technological, ethical, or intellectual threshold before revealing themselves – not unlike a cat assessing whether a human deserves its attention.

Detecting What Lies Beyond Our Senses

Even if they are reaching out, their methods of communication may be beyond our comprehension. Advanced civilizations might use forms of interaction far outside our technological reach, sending signals we fail to detect – just as a cat might fixate on something invisible to us, observing nuances we cannot.

Their signals could be encoded in gravitational waves, quantum fluctuations, or dimensions yet undiscovered – subtleties as imperceptible to us as the frequencies of sound cats hear beyond the range of human perception.

Quantifying the Possibility: The Drake Equation

If extraterrestrial silence is deliberate, it may not stem from failed communication but rather a choice to remain unseen. In an attempt to estimate the number of advanced civilizations in our galaxy, astrophysicist Frank Drake devised the Drake Equation (Wikipedia) in 1961. It breaks down this cosmic uncertainty, transforming speculation into measurable factors – considering variables such as star formation rates, habitable planets, and the probability of intelligent life emerging.

The equation is written as:

The Alien Cat Theory: What If Extraterrestrials Are Just Ignoring Us Like Cats?
The Drake equation

Where:

  • N = The estimated number of civilizations in the Milky Way galaxy capable of communicating with us
  • R* = The rate of star formation in our galaxy
  • fp = The fraction of stars with planetary systems
  • ne = The number of planets per star in the habitable zone
  • fl = The fraction of those planets where life actually arises
  • fi = The fraction of planets with life that evolves into intelligent beings
  • fc = The fraction of intelligent civilizations capable of interstellar communication
  • L = The length of time these civilizations remain detectable

As a basic illustration, plugging in values based on current scientific knowledge yields the following results: N = 1 × 0.2 × 1 × 1 × 1 × 0.1 × 1,000. This suggests that there could be approximately 20 detectable civilizations in the Milky Way galaxy under average assumptions.

The Fermi Paradox

So where is everybody? Physicist Enrico Fermi famously posed this question during a casual conversation in the summer of 1950. He questioned the absence of signs pointing to galactic colonization or the existence of advanced civilizations. Since then, it has become known as the Fermi Paradox (Wikipedia).

On the one hand, given the vastness of the universe – with billions of stars and potentially habitable planets – it seems statistically likely that intelligent extraterrestrial civilizations exist.

On the other hand, we have found no evidence of such advanced societies. This disparity between high probability and complete silence creates the paradox.

Maybe the silence isn’t due to a lack of communication, but a deliberate choice to remain unseen. What if this isn’t a paradox at all? Perhaps extraterrestrials are out there – watching from the shadows, yet choosing to remain unseen until they deem us worthy of recognition, just as the Zoo Hypothesis suggests. Likewise, as we reach into the great void, hoping for a response, perhaps we are merely waiting on civilizations that – like cats – exist yet remain indifferent to our effort.

The Cat Equation: The Cosmic Probability of Being Ignored

Philosophical inquiries and concepts – like the Drake Equation and the Fermi Paradox – offer intriguing cognitive exercises but no concrete conclusions. When considering advanced civilizations in our galaxy, we might do well to adopt the perspective of an alien cat – silent, elusive, watching from the shadows, revealing itself only when the moment is right… if it ever comes at all.

Perhaps what we truly need is a Cat Equation – one that embraces cosmic aloofness and acknowledges that intelligent beings, wherever they are, may simply be waiting for us to prove ourselves worthy of their attention.

The Cat Equation might take the form of: C = A × S × I × M × P × E × T

Where:

  • A = Aloofness factor (the tendency of intelligent beings to ignore lesser beings)
  • S = Selectivity threshold (how discerning they are in choosing whom to engage with)
  • I = Intelligence recognition coefficient (whether they acknowledge intelligence at all)
  • M = Mystery quotient (the extent to which they remain enigmatic)
  • P = Patience parameter (how long they’re willing to wait for a species to prove itself)
  • E = Engagement probability (chance that they’ll ever interact, given all prior conditions)
  • T = Tolerance for persistence (whether repeated attempts at contact are tolerated or ignored)

Earning Our Place in the Universe

Before we focus on proving our readiness to engage with civilizations beyond Earth, perhaps we should first demonstrate that we are worthy of one another – and of the planet we call home. Bridging our differences, cherishing our shared world, and approaching the cosmos not as impulsive explorers, but as stewards of wisdom and responsibility – perhaps that is the test. The signal they are waiting for.

Regardless of the outcome, this pursuit unites humanity in its curiosity and drives us to better understand our place in the cosmos.

As Arthur C. Clarke observed:

Feline Behavior Meets the Fermi Paradox: The Alien Cat Theory Explained

“Two possibilities exist: either we are alone in the Universe or we are not. Both are equally terrifying.”

Whether we are truly alone, merely ignored, or part of a waiting galactic community, the journey of exploration is as meaningful as the answer itself – perhaps even as enigmatic as a cat’s knowing gaze.


Stay tuned for more feline-fueled philosophy from David soon – because clearly, the cats know something we don’t.

Never Miss a Meow!

Cat in a box
David W. Falls

David W. Falls spent over three decades at Microsoft shaping the digital future – and now, in retirement, he’s letting cats reshape the philosophical one. Blending curiosity, science, and a dash of feline absurdity, David writes about the whiskered mysteries that mainstream physicists and philosophers are far too cautious to chase.

Articles: 12